energy news | ethanol | cellulose | algae | agriculture | biodiesel | oil/gas | wind | alt energy | carbon credits
RBAEF
Role of Biomass in America's Energy Future - Dartmouth Univ
Growing Energy report (pdf) - Dec 2004 - Pretty good analysis of a long-term energy strategy that includes substantial biofuels production from both grains and cellulose and conservation. Not included is the potential benefit of grid-powered transportation (all-electric and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles).
Good summary & commentary on the report - (July 2007)
Riverside Technologies
Proposed maker of an alternative to carbon black, from scrap tires. Could also work in producing ethanol. In the course of their pyrolysis process, 4 products are produced:
- 35% recycled carbon black
- 39% "middle distillate" oil
- 16% gas with either a Btu count of 1,200 or 1,500-1,800
- 10% scrap steel
Ethanol Industry Refutes Stanford E85 Study | CFDC
The Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) is the latest to join in the debate against the recently published Stanford report characterizing E85 as being more polluting than gasoline. The NRDC also strongly disagrees with Dr. Jacobson's conclusions. CFDC is excited about the onslaught of support we are receiving from such credible organizations such as NRDC and the Renewable Energy Action Project (REAP). We have also included the comments from the GEC and ACE on our website. Immediately following the NRDC statement is a copy of an article that appeared in the Biofuels Journal regarding the possibility of ExxonMobil supporting Stanford, and possibly the study by Jacobson.
NRDC Statement on New Study of Ethanol (E85) Impact on Air Quality,
NRDC believes there should be no rush to judgment on the impacts of ethanol used as high blends (E85, 85% ethanol, and 15% gasoline) on air quality based on a new study by Mark Z. Jacobson of
We urge Dr. Jacobson to join with NRDC, air pollution regulators, and scientists to clear the air regarding his statement that concludes that E85, “a high blend of ethanol poses an equal or greater risk to public health than gasoline.” This conclusion is at odds with previous studies and emission data from modern vehicles running on E85, and even appears to be at odds with the conclusion from his own study.
NRDC recommends the following to clarify the results of this paper and the air quality impacts of ethanol used as high blends:
· First, NRDC recommends that a team of leading vehicle emission experts review the existing data on emissions from E85. Based on this review, if the panel believes the emission scenarios in Dr. Jacobson’s study are incorrect and/or additional sensitivity runs are necessary, air pollution regulators should re-run the air pollution model to develop a broader scientific consensus of the impacts on air quality.
· Second, based on the results from the above work, we urge the CARB, US EPA, automakers and the ethanol industry to commit to additional testing of E85 vehicles if warranted. If such testing results indicate a need, we call upon CARB and US EPA to immediately set tighter emission standards on E85 vehicles to protect public health.
We look forward to working with Dr. Jacobson and vehicle emission experts to clarify and improve the quality of information being provided to policymakers and the public on this important issue of the pollution impacts of E85.
Roland Hwang, Vehicles Policy Director
NATURAL RESOURCES DEFENSE COUNCIL, www.nrdc.org
San Francisco, CA 94104
tel: 415-875-6100
fax: 415-875-6161
Biofuels Journal,
Group Says Stanford University Ethanol Study Tainted by ExxonMobil Ties (Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights)
| |
Mark Z. Jacobson, an associate professor of civil and environmental engineering, found that "a blend of ethanol poses an equal or greater [environmental health] risk than gasoline, which already causes significant health damage." His paper published in the online edition of Environmental Science and Technology said the research, based on computer models, was partly funded by NASA. The model is controversial because it assumes full conversion to ethanol use rather than partial. ExxonMobil has given $100 million to fund Stanford's Global Climate and Energy Program (GCEP). Though the ethanol study was not funded by that program, Jacobson had a three-year grant from GCEP to study the impact of replacing fossil-fuel motor vehicles and electric power plants with hydrogen fuel cell vehicles and power plants.
He is featured throughout a brochure about the Global Climate and Energy Program.
"It's difficult to accept a controversial study throwing cold water on the accepted idea that blended ethanol is a good solution to our energy problems when the university well that produced the study has been poisoned by Big Oil's money," said John M. Simpson, an FTCR advocate.
The science behind Jacobson's ethanol study could well be valid, FTCR said. However, the public cannot accept the results at face value when ExxonMobil has funded a major energy research program at the university and research results are in line with the giant oil firm's corporate goals, FTCR said. ExxonMobil Chairman Rex Tillerson is dismissive of ethanol's prospects, recently telling Fortune Magazine, "I don't have a lot of technology to add to moonshine." Jacobson said his ethanol work was not influenced by the corporate funding to the GCEP. "I completely oppose ExxonMobil and what it stands for," he said. He added that the results for the hydrogen research funded by GCEP, "resulted in me showing how unhealthful gasoline was relative to hydrogen, so it is certainly not a benefit to the oil companies."
Under the GCEP agreement ExxonMobil could control any patented results of hydrogen research, FTCR noted. "That's the problem when a university's administration takes Big Oil's cash and becomes part of Big Oil U.," said Simpson. "Even the very best work by its faculty members is greeted with justifiable skepticism from the public. "It's in the best interests of faculty and students alike to resist this corporatization of higher education."
The GCEP is managed and controlled by its corporate sponsors, not the university, FTCR noted. ExxonMobil has given $100 million to the GCEP. Other sponsors are Schlumberger,
The university has no vote on the committee, meaning that the research agenda can be set by the sponsoring firms. The committee can decide what patents will be sought. BP has proposed a similar $500 million deal with UC Berkeley that would create the Energy Biosciences Institute. That deal would bring 50 BP scientists to campus to do proprietary research and is under fire by many faculty members and students. The
At Stanford, ExxonMobil is touting its relationship with the university in a major advertising campaign. Objecting to ExxonMobil's greenwashing campaign, movie producer Steve Bing, who attended Stanford and had donated $22.5 million to the school, protested recently by canceling a $2.5 million pledge and any future donations.
See what's free at AOL.com.
Update on WY cellulose
David Pimentel
Dec 2006 interview with AlterNet - Aside from hating biofuels, he does highlight one important point that is generally not ever discussed: conservation is needed, is far more effective than any other strategy and is a long-term requirement.
Genetically Engineered Yeast Speeds Fermentation | MIT
MIT announced that they had developed a bakers yeast that is able to withstand the harsh ethanol environment and to yield a fermentation process that is 50% faster than what is otherwise possible.
Jointly funded by MIT-DuPont Alliance, NIH, US DOE, and the Singapore-MIT Alliance.
Improved Overall Ethanol production efficiency | CattleNetwork
Overall efficiency has improved as plants have become more standardized, more energy efficient. Further, improvements in corn hybrids mean more corn in marginal areas and more starch (and therefore more alcohol) from bushel.
9 Clouds on the Horizon for Ethanol \ checkbiotech.org
1. demand will increase corn costs
2. energy volatility will be transmitted to the ag markets
3. policy risk - the potential elimination or reduction in govt incentives and/or protection
4. more DDG use by livestock
5. modest local price increases for corn from the presence of ethanol plants (How is this different from (1)?)
6. railroads may not be able to expand quickly enough to support all needs
7. livestock producers should not count on reliable availability of DDG b/c of their potential use as a replacement for expensive natural gas and efforts to reprocess to get the residual starch out for ethanol...this could have the net effect of cutting supplies of available feed for livestock.
8. increasing use of fractionation could further cut feed availability for livestock producers. alternately, this could be good in that feed marketers may be able to develop new nutritional products for livestock from the new, more concentrated co-products that result.
9. as cellulosic production becomes economically viable, it is unknown whether or not existing corn-based producers will be affected in either a good or bad way.
Electricity Generation (reference)
Tenaska :: Tenaska Forms New Biofuels Marketing Company Based in Omaha, Tenaska has developed 9,000 MW of electric generating capacity (affiliates own/operate/manage 8 plants with 7,400 MW in 6 states).
U.S. Senate: Committees Home > Committee and Subcommittee Membership > Committee on Appropriations
US Senate committee with domain over rural development, including Kansas.
Kansas Ethanol (various)
Kansas ethanol plants (Kansas Energy Information Network...KEIN) - listing of plants and projects.
Conestoga Energy Partners (Finney, KS)
- Garden City - Broke ground on 5/25/06. Organized by BBI, design/built by ICM. 55mgy announced (they told us they will expand it to 110mgy as soon as it launches.
- Liberal - Planned at 110mgy, it hasn't broken ground yet.
Panda Group (Dallas, TX) – Panda's background is in electric power generation and wastewater mgmt. In 2005, they have announced three 100mgy projects (TX, CO, KS) through their Panda Energy subsidiary.
- Yuma, CO - Abandonned - This was to be a 100mgy plant.
- Haskel County, KS - 100mgy nameplate - They plan to use 1 bil lbs/yr of cow manure for biogas to run the plant; Mar 2006 approval on permits from state.
- Herford, TX - 100mgy, and also with manure-based biogas plan.
Ethanol Economics | (various)
- toledoblade.com - May 21, 2006
- Ethanol: A Tragedy in 3 Acts | BusinessWeek (May 2006) - Long anti-ethanol article that includes more than its fair share of inaccuracies and exaggerations. It is worth the read.
Ethanol: General Reference Info
- The Distillery and Fuel-Ethanol Network
- How Ethanol is created (pictorial guide from Corn Refiners Assoc)
- More reference info from Ethanol Capital Mgmt
Ethanol Production Companies
Industry Groups & Consultants
- BBI International - Biofuels Resource - feasibility studies & other biofuel consultancy services, including recruiting
- American Coalition for Ethanol (ACE) - The voice of the ethanol industry.
- Clean Fuels Development Coalition
Government:
- DOE - Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy site - State ethanol incentives (by state)
- Energy Information Administration (EIA) div of DOE US Gasoline reports (all sorts of wacky reports), International Petroleum Demand/Consumption
Financial:
- Ethanol Capital Mgmt an ethanol investment fund & advisory service includes some good reference materials on ethanol competitiveness.
- Ethanol Success Factors (PDF file) | Univ MN
Full analysis of the economic factors associated with success or failure of dry-mill ethanol plants utilizing corn as a feedstock.
American Ethanol (company profile)
- Plans to acquire/build 2mgy of ethanol production, most of their current plans in NE & IL.
- Delta-T investor
- Chairman was former World Wide Waste guy, as well as from Pacific Ethanol.
Reference: Cars
- FFV Vehicles and Accurate & current list of FFV choices in US
- GMs Live Green, Go Yellow campaign
- Saab's BioPower product line “ tuned to produce 20% greater hp when running on E85 v. gasoline. In Sweden, this version of their 9-5 2.0t accounted for 80% of sales for the 9-5 product line in 2005 (it costs ~$1,000 extra).
- Auto Spectator (2/24/06)
- 02/24/06 Auto SpectatorToyota embraces ethanol technology | FT.com (Apr 2006)
FFV Reference Info (incl E10 v E20+ debate)
FFV Reference
Required modifications (per Volvo):
- materials for fuel hoses, valves, seals and bushings are strengthened to deal with the increased corrosiveness of ethanol
- different injection system (v. standard gas) with recalibrated software
- a fuel sensor measure the mix of fuel in the gas tank and communicates with the injection system to get the appropriate mix and timing settings
- some vehicles may also include an engine heater to optimize cold-starting.
Zucarmex (company profile)
Grupo Zucarmex
- Dominican Republic - 1999 expansion
- Pictures of sugar plant
- Cargill has small stake in Zucarmex
Ethanol Blender Pumps | South Dakota Corn
A couple of SD coops are offering motorists the ability to choose between regular gas, E10, E20, E30 and E85. They are using a mechanim that has been in place for years, allowing diesel buyers to choose between blends of No 1 and No 2 diesel. More here
Butanol
reference site
Possible to made from corn, although less efficiently than ethanol (2.2-2.3 gal/bu). But, has higher energy content and be shipped through pipelines.
Biovance (company profile)
- HortResearch producing ultrasound approach to measuring hormones and glucose with non-invasive test. Similar, somewhat to Biovance method of screening cattle and monitoring the condition of bodies post-workout. [source: Wired]
Reference: Ethanol Plant Designers & Builders
- Fagen (Granite Falls, MN) - generally the contract builder for ICM designs. Most of their business is ethanol but there are some other power projects (wind).
- ICM (Colwich, KS) Design (CEO had ATF license #0001) plants that are generally built by Fagen- Phoenix Bio-Systems - make the zero-output wastewater treatment systems (a spin-off from ICM) - David VanderGriend (CEO of ICM)
- Broin Companies
- Broin & Assoc - dry mill plan engineering & construction
- Broin Mgmt - Mgmt services for ethanol plants built by Broin Assoc
- Dakota Gold Marketing - Distributor of DDGS from Broin Mmgt - supposedly "the only certified all-corn DDGS" in the US.
- Biofuels Solutions (Steamboat Springs, CO) – building Cargill plant(s) and also built Nordic BioFuels plant that was later sold to Abengoa.
- Abengoa companies: Abener (Engineering & Construction subs of Abengoa), ABRD (Abengoa Bioenergy Research & Development)
- Katzen International (Cincinnati, OH – est. 1955) – designers of a wide variety of ethanol plants (biomass, potato, grain, molasses – diagrams/flow charts for each type)
- Lurgi PSI – builder of one of Panda’s ethanol plants in the US. Lurgi PSI is the NA div of Lurgi AG, which is itself a subsidiary of GEA Group AG (Global Engineering Alliance). Lurgi is a world leader in the design & building of systems that produce bio-gas, as well as coal gasification. They are also builders of biodiesel plants in Europe. [? Do they have an IP to counter E3?]
- Vogelbusch (Vienna, Austria) – partnered with Siemens; they are the partner of record for the proposed Texas plant (from Mike Guben/Al Sutker).
- KL Process Design Group (Rapid City, SD) – Randy Kramer is the key guy
Reference: Ethanol Production Plants/Companies
- SEC filings for all LLC-based ethanol plants
General Indices:
- RFA listing of all US ethanol production facilities
- List of US ethanol plants (from EPAC – Ethanol Producers and Consumers)
Individual Plants & Operators:
- Abengoa Bioenergy (subs of Abengoa SA – Seville, Spain) – 3 (NE, NM, KS), 2 in Spain- US Energy – financing through CSFB. Spanish plant was built by Katzen. Through their SunOpta operation (JV? subsidiary?), they are building a cellulose-based plant, again with Katzen.
- E3 Biofuels - Designers of closed-loop system for feedlots & dairy farms. Using a anaerobic digestion method, manure produces biogas, which replaces or augments natural gas. WDG (wet distillers grains) is used as feed for cattle (24mgy fuel ethanol = 100k lbs WDG (40% of feed needs of 60k head of cattle)). They are a subsidiary of Earth Energy & Environment, LLC (Shawnee, KS).
- Front Range Energy (Windsor, CO) – 40mgy
- GTL Resources, PLC (UK) - Global Ethanol and Methanol projects- building 100mgy ICM/Fagan plant in Rochelle, IL
- Great Plains Ethanol – Chancellor, SD
- Panda Group (Dallas, TX) – Panda's background is in electric power generation and wastewater mgmt. In 2005, they have announced three 100mgy projects (TX, CO, KS) through their Panda Energy subsidiary.
- Yuma, CO - Rumor in the industry is that they have abandonned the option on this site.
- Haskel County, KS - 100mgy nameplate - They plan to use 1 bil lbs/yr of cow manure for biogas to run the plant; Mar 2006 approval on permits from state.
- Herford, TX - 100mgy, and also with manure-based biogas plan.
- US BioEnergy Corp (Brookings, SD) – Currently building 3 plants (100mgy Albert City, IA; 100mgy Janesville, MN; 45mgy Lake Odessa, MI). All of their plants are engineered by ICM and built by Fagen. Their stated goal is to be one of the biggest producers in the country in 5 years. In Nov 2005, they sold a 27% stake to CHS, an $11 billion coop-owned holding company for an undisclosed amount (CHS owns the Cenex chain of convenience stores & gas stations (#13 in US). United Bio Energy (UBE) is their services firm, providing plant mgmt, ethanol & DDGS marketing, and risk mgmt services to ethanol plants.
- VeraSun Energy – Big producer and distributor of ethanol and ethanol blends.
- Pacific Ethanol (PEIX) – Plans to build five west coast plants with production capacity of 200mgy. Kinergy Marketing is their wholly owned subsidiary for marketing ethanol (they have contracts with other ethanol producers, including Front Range and Phoenix BioSystems). Cascade Investment (Bill Gates’ fund) rec’d a 27% stake for $84 million. SFuels also has a large stake, and is their largest customer.
- Phoenix Bio-Industries – NOTE: Pacific Ethanol pulled out of an agreement to buy Phoenix.
Ethanol Financing | (various)
Understanding ethanol financing - Jan. 31, 2006
Good background on ethanol financing, including bits on CSFB and Abengoa.
Process Control Systems
Ethanol Producers Quickly Capitalize on Unprecedented Demand
Pavilion Technologies, a world leader in advanced process control (APC) and environmental compliance solutions, today announced that it has secured four additional customer commitments for its industry-leading ethanol APC Solution. Companies such as Adkins Energy, Badger State Ethanol and East Kansas Agri-Energy mark the latest group of ethanol manufacturers to deploy Pavilion's control solution to increase overall productivity and efficiency. More than 14 leading ethanol manufacturers have elected Pavilion's solutions to achieve emissions compliance, reduce energy costs, increase ethanol production, and enhance product yields."In just a year, we've seen an excellent return on investment from Pavilion," said Glacial Lakes Energy plant manager, David Culver. "Pavilion enables us to control the distillation columns and molecular sieves processes, which are challenging to manage optimally and yet critical to achieve our operating objectives - more, high quality ethanol for less. Furthermore, we are able to continuously reduce our energy usage. And in today's marketplace, being able to produce more ethanol at higher yields equals real money."As the demand for alternative fuels grows and manufacturers seek strategies to quickly capitalize on record-high ethanol prices, Pavilion provides an effective technology solution to enable the production of more high quality ethanol for less. Simultaneously, ethanol manufacturers can drive down energy costs, combating the sky rocketing prices for natural gas. This helps ethanol producers achieve two key goals: more efficient use of energy and a "greener" end product.Pavilion's software - Pavilion8(tm) - combines powerful predictive and dynamic control capabilities which allow manufacturers to more effectively control complex processes exhibited in the production of ethanol. With Pavilion's control solution, ethanol manufacturers have improved the performance of the dryer, evaporator, thermal oxidizer, mole sieve distillation and other stages of the production cycle. Most customers report a payback in 2 - 6 months on projects completed in 8 - 16 weeks."As consumers clamor for 'greener' fuel sources, ethanol companies are working to meet demand," said Pavilion Technologies CEO, Ralph Carter. "We are honored that leaders like Broin Companies, Glacial Lakes, and Badger State Ethanol look to us as a partner that will help deliver rapid value."www.pavtech.com
Net Energy Debate | Univ Cal Berkeley
Net energy balance and greenhouse gas emissions profile of ethanol - that was the focus of a study conducted by Alex Farrell, Daniel Kammen, et al, at Univ of Cal Berkeley, published in 2006. They compared studies published over the last several years, from a variety of sources. They put together a model that highlighted the strengths and weaknesses, and holes, in each of the studies. One result was the calculation of a weighted average net energy balance and GHG calculation for corn-based ethanol. Another larger benefit was the better, more complete understanding that is possible after seeing each of these studies side by side, seeing how their various assumptions inflate or deflate the end results.
Salon articles
- Jan 27, 2006 release of study
- Oct 10, 2006 speech by Tad Padzek
- How much energy does it cost to produce ethanol? A response to Ted Patzek's claims
- Actual publication from UC-Berkeley (pdf)
- Analysis from NRDC
2001 study from USDA (pdf)
reference materials
Governor's Ethanol Coalition | 2006 announcement
Sebelius leads ethanol coalition - 2006-01-05
Kansas governor, a Democrat, takes over leadership spot of Governors' Ethanal Coalition from Minnesota Gov. Tim Pawlenty, a Republican. Nebraska Gov Dave Heineman, a Republican, will be vice chair in 2006.
KL Process Design (company profile)
Operations
- Midwest Renewable Energy, LLC - Sutherland, NE - 15-18 mgy
- North Country Ethanol, LLC - Rosholt, SD - (news – see blurb about 2003 explosion)
- KL Process Design, LLC - Rapid City, SD
Reference: Pipelines & Terminals
Pipelines, Terminals and Refineries
Refined product pipelines (v. crude oil pipelines) - vary in size from 8-12" up to 42" diameter. In the US, there are 95,000 miles of this type of pipeline, in almost all states (except some New England states). The rates they charge "shippers" are regulated, by the feds & states.
How many pipelines are there (pipeline101.com)?
Reference: Markets
- Historical pricing (by month) - from the state of Nebr
- Live prices (CBOT)
- Ethanol Marketing.com - Ethanol, Corn, Beans, Crude Oil, Nat Gas, Heating Oil, Propane, Sugar, Currencies
- Ethanol rack prices (by state)
- Existing US power plants (eia.doe.gov)
- Oil market prices (eia.doe.gov)
- Corn, wheat, ethanol spot prices (Chicago Board of Trade)
- Garden City Coop
- Prices by state (Axxis Petroleum)
Anerobic Digesters & Biogas
Definition
Manufacturers/Designers
- RCM Digesters (Berkeley, CA) – along with someone else, they are building the digester for E3 in Mead, NE; founded in 1982; Mark Moser (founder & president)
Waste Management players
- Synagro (supposedly the largest, and only nationally-focused player, recycler of biosolids and organic residuals in the US).
Types
- Plug Flow systems are unmixed, heated rectangular tanks that digest raw manure (11 - 13% solids) from ruminant animals. They function horizontally. Energy recovery is optimized. Digested dairy solids can be separated and sold as a new product.
- Complete Mix systems produce biogas from a variety of organic wastes with 3 to 10% total solids content. These digesters are heated and mixed to maintain a high level of bacterial activity to optimize energy production for the farm.
- Covered Lagoon – These produce biogas at ambient temperatures from diluted manure with less than 2 percent solids. Biogas yield varies seasonally. Covered lagoons are used for energy production in warm climates but are limited to odor control in cold climates.
- Heated Mix Covered Lagoon (swine) – A hybrid system to optimize manure treatment and biological stabilization for odor control rather than energy production. The system is able to handle varying manure flows, but relatively inexpensive to build and operate.
- Electricity generation (one example in Monterey, CA)
Closed Loop Systems
Underwood, ND - New ethanol production facility to be built next to electric generation facility; the excess heat from that plant will be used for the ethanol production process, saving $15 million in capital costs for the ethanol plant
Panda Energy - Have announced the building of three 100mgy plants that will all utilize shit-to-biogas for some/all of their heating requirements. Note that they have announced their intentions to build a total of five of these 100mgy plants. The Hereford, TX plant will be built by Lurgi PSI (US office is in Memphis - based in Frankfurt, German - more here under Ethanol Plant Designers). Profile article on Todd Clark/Panda in Houston Chronicle.
E3 BioFuels (aka Nebraska BioClean) - Building ethanol plant on location with 30,000 head feedlot in Mead, NE; 24mgy facility will have zero natural gas needs; WDG will supply 40% of feed needs of the cattle. Cost, including feedlot and shit processor is $71 million. US Patent 6,355,456 (filed Jan 19, 2000; David Hallberg & Victor W Schlesinger, assigned to Dakota Ag Energy, Inc.) covers an integrated continuous process for the production of ethanol and a bio-gas containing methane, involving a feedlot with slatted floors, the cattle being fed a diet with a range of 25-80% WTG.
Sunrise Energy Cooperative - Small-scale (5 mgy) system, designed by Katzen. Unsure of current status. A case study (pdf), funded by an Illinois org, was done in 2001.
Reference: State by State Comparison
Hawaii
- Biomass Energy Fact Sheet - biomass from sugar, biodiesel from vegetable oil
- Availability and costs of biomass materials - in addition to sugar cane, there are references to ? and ? as other sources of ethanol.
- Pacific Biodiesel - they had the first commercially viable biodiesel plant in the US (started in 1997).
- Ethanol in Hawaii (summary) (more - pdf)
Notes on Plant Costs/Operations
Notes on Plant Costs/Operations
Size - 50-60mgy dry mill ethanol production
Natural Gas
- Requirements: 1.5-1.8 million Btu per year; Per denatured gallon, 30,000-34,000 is required for DDGS, and about 22,000 for WDG (wet).
- 20 mile pipeline with necessary modifications – in the Laurel example, this was estimated to cost $3-5 million.
Electricity
- Requirements: 3.75-4.8 MW, based on .75-.80 kWh/gallon ethanol, at $.03-.05/kWh.
- Cogeneration - how much could be generated? At what capital cost? Would excess be sold back to local/regional utility? Could it be marketed separately ?
Water
- 180-270 million gallons water/year (4.5 gal per 1 gal ethanol produced)
- Rights - consideration needs to be given to water rights and ability of wells or other local sources to provide long-term.
- Recirculation systems - see ____.
Management & Marketing
- Broin mgmt - $450,000 annual fee, including a GM and technical manager(s?), plus an incentive fee of 5% of annual net income.
- Ethanol marketing (Broin) - $.085/gallon
- distillers grain - Dakota Gold (another Broin co) is 3% of gross monthly sales (gross? How and why is that different from net?).
- United Bio Energy (UBE) - full range of services, like Broin companies, for $550,000/year plus 4% of net profits for plant mgmt, $.01/gal for ethanol and 2% of net for the feed.
Reference: Brazilian Ethanol
Brazil facts
World Summit on Ethanol - Brazilian presentation - Nov2003 (Quebec)
- Ethanol has consumed 50-80% of the sugarcane crop since the mid-80's. - Use of ethanol, in all mixed percentages, peaked in the mid-80's at just over 60%, declined to just under 30% until around 2000 and has increased significantly since then. - E95/100 vehicles (Nov 2003) $2.3 million; E20/25 (Nov 2003) $16 million - Sugar/Ethanol prices "there DOES appear to be a correlation between the two prices (p28)
- $25/bbl breakeven for Brazilian sugar-based ethanol
- 11/18/05 – Cosan (CSAN3.SA) went public on the Sao Paolo exchange; 70% of the shares were purchased by foreign investors (1/2 were US). They raised $365 million, most of which is planned to invested in consolidation and other expansion.
- from Citigroup analysis - cost of sugar production is rising, both on an average and incremental basis. Factors affecting the overall average cost include devaluation of the currency (Real), port constraints (?) and lifts in investment requirements (?). Incremental production is generally further west of current markets, areas that have lower yields because of soil infertility and declining rainfall, as well as higher transportation costs.
News
Brazil Looks to Jamaica for US Market - After the EU cut price supports for former colonies, Jamaica's state-owned sugar business is in trouble. Two companies from Brazil have offered to invest in ethanol production, hoping to take advantage of Jamaica's participation in the CBI and their duty-free status on ethanol (up to 7% of US demand).
Are Protective Tariffs & Quotas for Ethanol Doomed? - Brazil recently won a trade dispute with the EU on their sugar subsidies, forcing real changes that will affect more than Europe & Brazil. Brazil is turning its attention to the protected US market for both sugar & ethanol producers.
Debate on E20 and other ethanol blends that exceed 10% for non-FFV use
Durability
- Australian discussion on permissible limit (2002) Original limit (2000) was only 7.8% based on the maximum oxygen content limit; this was later revised to 10%, or 3.5% oxygen content. This discussion was driven by the creation of a task force to consider higher percentages, from above 10% up to 20%. The local car industry (FCAI) opposed a proposal to allow for up to 20% ethanol because of engine calibration and durability issues.
- Fuel Quality Publications (Australia) standards for biodiesel, ethanol percentage (E10 v. E20), cetane & octane discussion, etc. - Actual results of testing of cars with different fuels: Gasoline, E10, and E20, tested over 80,000 km (50k mi) in five different types of cars. Full details are here but, there did appear to be slight differences in wear (E20 had more) between fuels. And, there was a substantial increase in the NOx, THM, and CO emissions from E20 cars (the extra oxygen content generated more heat, which burns out the elements in the catalyst).
- More discussion from Australia.
Fuel economy/efficiency
- ACE Fuel Economy Study (8/24/05) - Performed by Allen Kasperson (fuel research specialist) at Lake Area Vocational Technical Institute (Watertown, SD), using E10, E20 and E30 in three cars (Taurus, Impala, Camry), none of which were FFV equipped. Measuring relative fuel economy (rather than durability) was the purpose of the 600 miles/car test. In addition to the 3 ethanol blends noted, they also tested a version of E10 that had been specially denatured with a mixture of soy diesel and another additive (link to the actual study in PDF). Results: showed that the average loss in fuel economy was substantially less than suggested by the lower BTU content; this suggested that the higher oxygen content enabled a more efficient burning of the overall fuel mixture.
Legal
- March 2007 - Sen Thune proposes raising limit to 20% for conventional (non-FFV) vehicles.
- MN E20 Law - Requires that 20% of the state's liquid fuel use be 20% renewable by 2010. If that goal is not met through the use of E10 and E85, the state has mandated the switching of E10 to E20 by 2013. This does not yet have approval or support from the EPA. (more here)
- Thailand - Ford is moving to make its entire fleet compatible with E20 without modification (separate from those with E85 FFV designation).
Reference: International
Other international requirements
- Canada: target to raise overall national average from 1% to 3.5% by 2010
- EU: targeting 5.75% of motor fuel (gasoline only, overall?) by 2010; per Lurgi's website, demand for biofuels will increase from 5 million tons (?) to 14 million tons by 2010. An estimated 100 new plants will be required to meet that demand, unless it is imported.
- India: recently announced 5% requirement in 9 states; likely to be rolled out to additional states later. What is schedule? What states, of how many, and of what % of vehicle population? 5% of gasoline, or overall total?
- China: target for renewable energy consumption of 10% by 2020
- Thailand: target 2% of projected energy needs by 2010, using 5% ethanol; Ford has recently introduced cars/trucks capable of running 20%
- Japan: 3% ethanol level targeted; biofuel level of 7% targeted for 2010
Regional Trade Pacts
- State Dept summaries
- NAFTA
- CAFTA - Costa Rica, El Salvador, Guatemala, Nicaragua, and the Dominican Republic- CBI (Caribbean Basin Initiative) -
- Andean Region Free Trade Agreement - Under negotiation, with a goal of completion by the end of 2005. US, Columbia, Peru and Ecuador are participants, with Bolivia an observer that has the option of joining later.
- FTAA (Free Trade Area of the Americas) - Discussions are currently stalled after 9 years, driven by divisions between the co-chairs, Brazil & the US, over the concept of a two-tiered framework comprised by a set of common rights & obligations for all countries, to be augmented by a series of additional plurilateral agreements.
Reference
- DOE's by-country analysis of energy (search for country)Corn production - Mexico - (USDA report 2004) Net importer, primarily of yellow corn for cattle feed; white corn (used for tortillas) are produced domestically, protected by farm subsidy payments. Imports from the US account for 25% of corn in Mexico. Most production is concentrated in the southern states, particularly Oaxaca, Jalisco & Chiapas.
Great Plains Ethanol (a Broin company plant)
Chancellor, SD
40,000 gpy
10-Q Report (June 2005)
- LLC formed in 2000
- Construction loan June 2002
- Plant first operational March 2003
- Built by Broin
- Managed by Broin Mgmt (“we are entirely dependant on up Broin Mgmt, LLC to manage day-to-day operationsâ€) – includes also marketing of ethanol (by Ethanol Products, LLC) & DDGS (by Dakota Gold Marketing), and also risk mgmt svcs.
- Ethanol prices declined in Q2/05, in spite of rising gas prices – drive entirely by supply.
